Appliance Part Help
Buying guide

Whole house water filter cartridges: the most-bought replacements

A whole house filter only works if the cartridge fits the housing, so this guide ranks what shoppers actually buy rather than giving opinions. It covers the 12 most-bought cartridge numbers out of 26 we compare, from 3M Aqua-Pure, Pentair Pentek, GE, Whirlpool and DuPont housings.

The makers' own cartridges take 44% of estimated Amazon sales across these numbers. The rest goes to 24 other brands, many of which list several makers' numbers on one cartridge because the sizes are standard.

Updated November 18, 2026. Sales shares are estimates for June to October 2026.

26part numbers compared
17%of sales go to AP110
44%bought as the maker's own filter or part
24aftermarket brands

The 12 most-bought water filter cartridge part numbers

Share of estimated Amazon sales across all 26 numbers; the 12 shown here are the most bought. Open a part to compare every replacement.

  1. 13M AP11017% of sales

    3M Aqua-Pure's 10 x 2.5 inch sediment cartridge for the AP100 series housing. A standard size: many listings also name Culligan P5 and Whirlpool WHKF-GD05.

    13 listings from 8 brands, including 3M's own part. Most-bought aftermarket: Aquaboon, AQUA CREST, ICEPURE.

    Compare AP110 replacements
  2. 2GE FXHTC16% of sales

    GE's sediment and carbon cartridge for GE whole house housings such as the GXWH40L and GXWH35F. A 10 x 4.5 inch size, so many compatible cartridges also list Culligan and Pentek numbers.

    18 listings from 11 brands, including GE's own part. Most-bought aftermarket: Culligan, AQUA CREST, Waterdrop.

    Compare FXHTC replacements
  3. 3Pentair DGD-5005-2011% of sales

    Pentek's 20 x 4.5 inch Big Blue sediment cartridge, 5 micron. Also sold as 155358-43.

    11 listings from 5 brands, including Pentair's own part. Most-bought aftermarket: Max Water, Aquaboon, Tier1.

    Compare DGD-5005-20 replacements
  4. 43M AP4318% of sales

    3M Aqua-Pure's scale inhibitor cartridge for whole house scale control; it reduces scale rather than filtering sediment.

    6 listings from 4 brands. Most-bought aftermarket: Waterdrop, AQUA CREST, IT'S PURE EXPERT.

    Compare AP431 replacements
  5. 5Pentair DGD-50055% of sales

    Pentek's 10 x 4.5 inch Big Blue sediment cartridge, 5 micron.

    3 listings from 3 brands, including Pentair's own part. Most-bought aftermarket: BLUEFLO, Aquaboon.

    Compare DGD-5005 replacements
  6. Whirlpool's 10 x 2.5 inch carbon wrap cartridge for chlorine taste and odor. Many listings also name GE FXWTC.

    6 listings from 3 brands, including Whirlpool's own part. Most-bought aftermarket: Aquaboon, Max Water.

    Compare WHKF-WHWC replacements
  7. 7Pentair R50-BB4% of sales

    Pentek's 10 x 4.5 inch Big Blue pleated sediment cartridge, 50 micron (coarse), washable.

    7 listings from 4 brands, including Pentair's own part. Most-bought aftermarket: ICEPURE, PUREPLUS, SpiroPure.

    Compare R50-BB replacements
  8. 83M AP8104% of sales

    3M Aqua-Pure's carbon cartridge for the AP800 series housing.

    2 listings from 2 brands. Most-bought aftermarket: Waterdrop, AQUA CREST.

    Compare AP810 replacements
  9. 9DuPont WFPFC30024% of sales

    DuPont's 10 x 2.5 inch pleated sediment cartridge. A standard size; many listings also name Whirlpool WHKF-WHPL.

    6 listings from 4 brands. Most-bought aftermarket: PUREPLUS, Membrane Solutions, Aquaboon.

    Compare WFPFC3002 replacements
  10. 10Pentair DGD-7525-203% of sales

    Pentek's 20 x 4.5 inch Big Blue sediment cartridge, 25 micron.

    8 listings from 3 brands, including Pentair's own part. Most-bought aftermarket: Tier1, SpiroPure.

    Compare DGD-7525-20 replacements
  11. 113M AP917HD3% of sales

    3M Aqua-Pure's quick-change cartridge for the AP900 series housings such as the AP904. Listings also name AP903; check your housing first.

    7 listings from 5 brands, including 3M's own part. Most-bought aftermarket: Elovener, Pelicori, PERCOLA.

    Compare AP917HD replacements
  12. 123M AP810-23% of sales

    3M Aqua-Pure's 20 x 4.5 inch sediment cartridge for the AP800 series. Many listings also name Pentek ECP5-20BB.

    8 listings from 5 brands, including 3M's own part. Most-bought aftermarket: PUREPLUS, ICEPURE, Aquaboon.

    Compare AP810-2 replacements

Most-bought water filter cartridge brands

Share of estimated Amazon sales across all 26 part numbers. Makers' own parts are grouped under the maker.

  1. Pentair (maker's own)28%
  2. Aquaboon18%
  3. Waterdrop9%
  4. AQUA CREST9%
  5. 3M (maker's own)7%
  6. GE (maker's own)7%
  7. PUREPLUS5%
  8. ICEPURE5%
  9. Culligan3%
  10. Whirlpool (maker's own)2%

How to match a cartridge to your housing

  • Read the old cartridge. The maker's number is printed on it or on the housing label.
  • Or measure it. Standard sizes are 10 x 2.5 inch (standard), 20 x 2.5 inch (slim tall), 10 x 4.5 inch and 20 x 4.5 inch (Big Blue). A cartridge of the right size from another brand usually fits.
  • Pick the media. Sediment cartridges (rated in microns: lower is finer) catch sand and rust; carbon cartridges reduce chlorine taste and odor. Two-stage systems use one of each.

How to change a whole house cartridge

  • Turn off the water before the filter (or use the bypass valve) and press the pressure-release button on the housing.
  • Unscrew the housing bowl with the housing wrench, keeping it upright so it does not spill.
  • Swap the cartridge, rinse the bowl, and check and lubricate the O-ring with food-grade silicone grease.
  • Screw the bowl back on hand-tight plus a little with the wrench, turn the water on slowly, hold the pressure button to let air out, and check for leaks.
  • Run a tap for a few minutes to flush a new carbon cartridge.

Frequently asked questions

How often should I change a whole house water filter?

Usually every 3 to 6 months for sediment and carbon cartridges, sooner if water pressure drops or the water is dirty. Check the maker's gallon rating for your cartridge.

What is the most bought whole house filter cartridge?

By estimated Amazon sales, AP110, at about 17% of sales across the 26 whole house cartridge numbers we compare.

Do other brands' cartridges fit my housing?

Usually, if the size matches (for example 10 x 4.5 inch Big Blue) and the listing names your housing or cartridge number. Many compatible cartridges list several makers' numbers for that reason.

What is the most-bought whole house cartridge brand?

Pentair, with about 28% of estimated Amazon sales across the cartridges we compare. The makers' own cartridges take 44% in total.

As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Sales shares are our estimates of Amazon sales and are rounded. Aftermarket parts are made by third parties, not by the filter makers. How this works